1. An Unexpected Night

Transcript

It's been a full day, one that's left me aching for a quiet night with a glass of wine. Thankfully by the time I get home from my day out on the town, Andrew is out with friends. A normal Saturday.

I pour myself a glass of wine and make myself comfortable on the couch. The latest episode of The Morning Show with Jennifer Aniston is waiting. Wrapping a blanket around myself, I snuggle in.

My phone rings, and the name Johanna flashes across the screen. Johanna. Someone I hadn't heard from in several years.

Still, I answer the phone and put it to my ear. Sarah, I found your husband! He says he's already leaving even though it's still so early.

Is it okay if I come back with him, just for a drink and to say hi to you? Uh, sure, I answer without thinking. Sarah and I had fun together when we were in high school.

We traded kisses, secrets, passions, and touches, until of course, Andrew walked into my life. He clarified all the confusion I felt, and I fell in love very quickly. Only a few years later, and we're married.

Even if things have slipped a little in the passion department and autopilot has kicked in, I know that I'm happy with Andrew and that I made the right choice. Jo didn't like Andrew back then. The fact that she's determined to come home with him now to have a glass of wine with us leads me to down my glass.

Something is definitely up with her. I don't have time to think about it. I splash some water on my face, slide into a pair of jeans and a t-shirt, and run a brush through my hair to hide the fact that I'd been half ready for sleep.

Just as I return to the living room, the door lock clicks. Johanna and Andrew come through the door. Andrew kisses my cheek gently.

Good evening, Sarah. Johanna walks directly to me, wrapping me in a warm hug. We all sit down at the dining table as I uncork a bottle of red wine for us.

Johanna wraps her delicate fingers around the stem of her glass and brings it to her full lips, her eyes glancing at me in a way that I remember, sending goosebumps skittering over my skin. Reaching across the table, she takes me tightly. I've missed you.

Tell me everything that you've been up to. As I answer her, updating her on work, married life, and the latest episodes of TV I've binged, Andrew excuses himself to go to the bathroom. Johanna scoots her chair closer, eyes flicking between the doorway Andrew just used to leave and me.

I've been thinking back to our high school days so much, Sarah. Do you remember all the things we tried? The trouble we got into? I study her eyes.

Sure, there's more on her mind. Her hand strokes my wrist and she smiles softly. Her eyes are like magnets, pulling me closer until her hand slides around the back of my neck and her lips begin moving against mine.

Her breath over my lips makes me tremble as I lean away and blush. I'm married. This can't be right for us to do.

I have to convince my eager body that's warming under her gaze to calm down. But Johanna's fingers trail my jaw and pull me in for another kiss. Johanna's tongue teases mine into a dance I haven't been able to forget.

Slow and sure, her tongue stroking mine as I fight the urge to melt against her. She gently bites my bottom lip, making me a trembling mess. Hearing a door shut, I draw back.

Andrew leans against the doorway with the slightest smirk to his face. Am I disturbing anything? No.

I clear my throat and brush my hands down my shirt. Not at all. Do you mind if… Yo… Johanna sleeps over tonight? His eyes flick to Johanna and he shifts a little uncomfortably.

No, honey, I don't mind at all. Andrew giggles and turns my attention back to her by grabbing my chin. Instead of kissing me right away, her hands slide over my body.

I feel my nipples harden as she strokes down my neck, over my back, and then round to cup my breasts. Her thumb runs circles round my nipples. I pant and welcome her lips on mine again.

I lick into her mouth and tease until she moans. Dragging herself away, she pushes the table to the side and drags me up. Join us, Andrew.

He reaches out to us and we move towards him. Yo catches my shirt and pulls me back against her. She drags my shirt off and turns me around into a dance that becomes more as our hips move against each other.

I unbutton her shirt, exposing her white bra as she trails her fingers over my bare chest. Andrew catches my hips and draws me back against him, cradling my bottom against the hardness in his jeans. He guides one of my hands back to rub his cock after he unzips his jeans.

His teeth catch my ear and I moan. Back arching, Johanna licks across one of my nipples eagerly. Let's go to bed, all of us, I hum, lost in the pleasure of their bodies against mine.

Once in bed, Johanna and I shove Andrew back on the bed and tug his pants and boxers off. I climb up next to him as Johanna frees me of my own jeans. I kiss him hungrily as his fingers thread through my hair.

Johanna's fingers tease my pussy as she climbs onto the bed. I watch her lick from the root to the tip of Andrew's cock. Andrew cups my breasts and sucks my nipple into his mouth, kissing and licking until I moan for him.

Johanna continues teasing Andrew's cock until his eyes are as needy as I feel. Pulling Johanna up, I kiss her again, tasting both her and Andrew at once. I gently touch her nipple, feeling it harden under my fingers.

Pushing her back next to Andrew, I lower myself between her legs, kissing and licking along the inside of her thighs. Andrew tugs on her thong, moving it out of the way so I can lick her clit and tease her pussy. I lap at her pussy, tongue exploring and memorising, just like when we were younger.

Drawing back, I adjust so I'm on my knees with my ass in the air. Andrew, please take me. He groans and moves behind me, jerking my hips against his so he's buried inside me.

I moan hard as Johanna echoes the sound. He teases me, only giving me half his cock as I keep devouring Jo's sweetness. Finally, he thrusts all the way in, making my whole body shake.

It doesn't take long for all of us to come. We lay in a messy pile, legs a tangled mess as I try to touch them both. We're not done, Sarah.

Johanna kisses the back of my shoulder. You have me all night. I grin and kiss her eagerly, ready for the next round.